Abstract
The advent of environmental DNA (eDNA) represents a pivotal advancement in probing mesophotic communities, offering a non-intrusive avenue for studying marine biodiversity at greater depths. Using this approach, we characterized and compared the mesophotic reef fish assemblages of two West Indian Ocean islands, Mayotte and La Réunion, which are characterized by different geo-morphological contexts. The sequences obtained were assigned taxonomically and grouped into molecular operational taxonomic units to perform richness and beta diversity analyses. The functional diversity of the assemblages was assessed using five traits, enabling each sequence to be assigned to a functional entity corresponding to a specific trait combination. On both islands, the fish assemblages exhibited a comparable level of taxonomic and functional richness, consisting mainly of piscivorous and planktivorous fishes. These assemblages were primarily composed of families such as Serranidae, consistent with expectations for the mesophotic zone. However, beta diversity analyses revealed that the two islands exhibited different taxonomic and functional structures. For example, La Réunion was characterized by a greater importance of the Muraenidae, while Mayotte displayed a higher representation of families strongly associated with coral reefs (e.g., Zanclidae or Malacanthidae). These results suggest that depth-related forcing constrains fish assemblages to some extent, but that differences in structure remains determined by other, more local factors, likely linked to the geo-morphological contexts of the islands and their habitats. This study also revealed that eDNA is a promising method for studying difficult-to-observe taxa, such as moray eels or lanternfish, and may also be relevant for monitoring species depth ranges. Overall, results highlighted the “local scale”, “functionally integrative” and “temporally integrative” characteristics of eDNA for studying mesophotic reef fish assemblages. However, this study also highlights the limitations of reference DNA databases, pointing to future prospects for fully exploiting the potential of eDNA approaches in the mesophotic zones of the Indian Ocean.